Strict Parenting vs Soft Parenting: What Actually Works? | Psychologist Explains

Parenting is one of the most challenging roles in life, often leaving parents caught in a dilemma: should they be strict disciplinarians or soft, permissive guardians? In this clinical segment from The Buzz Bite, psychologist Ms. Pragya Pushkarna, founder of Psychologist Near You, examines these two extremes. Both parenting styles are driven by a desire to protect and guide children, yet both can lead to unintended emotional and behavioral struggles if taken to excess. Pragya shares insight into how finding a balanced approach supports healthy childhood development.

Strict parenting, characterized by high demands and low responsiveness, focuses heavily on obedience, rules, and control. While it may produce outward discipline in the short term, clinical research shows it can lead to anxiety, low self-esteem, and secrecy in children, who may behave well only out of fear of punishment rather than understanding. On the other hand, soft or permissive parenting, which offers high warmth but few boundaries, can create a different set of challenges. Without structured rules, children often struggle with self-regulation, boundary setting, and handling frustration or failure in the outside world.

The key to effective parenting lies in finding a balanced approach, often referred to in psychology as authoritative parenting. This style combines clear, consistent boundaries with emotional warmth, active listening, and open communication. Instead of imposing rules without explanation, authoritative parents explain the reasons behind guidelines and validate their child's feelings. This combination of structure and emotional safety helps children build self-discipline, decision-making skills, and emotional resilience.

More in Psychology